A Hoosier Favorite: Sugar Cream Pie
A closer look at sugar cream pie, with creamy vanilla filling and a cinnamon finish.
Read the guideHandmade pies & custom cakes. Columbia City, Indiana. Local pickup Fri–Sun · 10am–6pm. Pies & custom cakes: order one week ahead.
the journal
Notes on cakes, pies, and planning your next order.
A closer look at sugar cream pie, with creamy vanilla filling and a cinnamon finish.
Read the guideA few practical details to arrange before you collect your wedding cake.
Read the guideThe difference between a classic apple pie and a Dutch apple pie comes down to the topping.
Read the guideChoose your flavors, decide on decoration, and leave time to arrange your holiday pickup.
Read the guideA few details to gather before asking about a cake for your shower.
Read the guideLet us know when you plan to serve your pie so you can confirm the right care instructions.
Read the guideStart with flavors you enjoy, then discuss the available cake and filling options.
Read the guide