Planning Your Thanksgiving Pie Order

Start with your guest count and the flavors people enjoy. A mix of fruit, cream, and nut pies gives guests a choice, but a smaller gathering may only need one favorite. Check the serving information on each product page before deciding how many to order.

Prices and decoration

Plain 9-inch pies are $30. Florals are an optional $20 add-on, making a decorated pie $50. Select the finish for each pie before adding it to your cart.

Timing and pickup

Pies need at least one week of notice. Regular pickup is Friday through Sunday, 10am–6pm, in Columbia City. For Thanksgiving or another date outside those regular windows, contact us to confirm availability before making plans.

Choose a pickup date close to when you will serve your pies. If you have ingredient questions or are ordering several flavors, include those details when you get in touch. Your confirmed order will include the pickup address.