A Hoosier Favorite: Sugar Cream Pie

Sugar cream pie is a Hoosier favorite with a simple combination of creamy vanilla filling, flaky crust, and a lightly caramelized cinnamon top. It is a good choice when you want a pie without a fruit filling.

Choose your finish

Our sugar cream pie is 9 inches. Order it plain for $30, or choose the optional floral decoration for $20 more, bringing the total to $50. The floral finish is an add-on; it is not included with a plain pie.

Before you order

Ask us about ingredients and allergies before ordering. The product page has the decoration choices. Please allow one week of notice. If you are ordering for a gathering, choose the pickup date closest to when you plan to serve it and include any questions with your order.