Skip to content

Handmade pies & custom cakes. Columbia City, Indiana. Local pickup Fri–Sun · 10am–6pm. Pies & custom cakes: order one week ahead.

All posts

Apple Pie or Dutch Apple Pie?

1 min readBy Lilyana, founder & head baker
Pie with a floral lattice crust

Both apple pies on our menu start with sliced apples, sugar, and warm spices. If you are deciding between them, think about which topping you would enjoy most.

Classic apple pie

Our Apple Pie has a flaky pastry crust. It is a familiar choice for anyone who likes the combination of spiced apples and golden pie dough.

Dutch apple pie

Dutch Apple Pie swaps the pastry top for a buttery crumble. The apple filling sits in a flaky bottom crust, with the crumble adding a different texture to each slice.

Make it yours

Both are 9-inch pies at $30 plain. Optional floral decoration adds $20, for a $50 total. Choose your finish on the product page, where you can choose your finish. If you have a flavor preference or a question about an ingredient, get in touch before ordering.

Have a wedding cake question?

Email hello@birdiesbakingco.com with your date, venue, and guest count.

Start an inquiry