Skip to content

Handmade pies & custom cakes. Columbia City, Indiana. Local pickup Fri–Sun · 10am–6pm. Pies & custom cakes: order one week ahead.

a Hoosier favorite

Sugar cream pie

Creamy vanilla filling in a flaky crust, finished with a lightly caramelized cinnamon top.

$30 plain · $50 with florals

Each pie is 9 inches. Floral decoration is an optional $20 add-on. Please order at least one week ahead.

Please ask about ingredients, allergies, and storage before ordering.